Smart Choice Catering
“Pleasing Palates Since 1975”

3623 East Independence Blvd.
Charlotte, NC 28205
Phone: 704-532-2800

Email Link

Looking for something unique, delicious and fun to eat for your next ice cream social, barbecue or party? Try our delicious homemade and hand-dipped Key Lime Pies. We start with made from scratch Key Lime Pie using real key lime juice and a graham cracker crust. The pie is cut into generous wedges, frozen and inserted with a popsicle stick. Then each bar is hand dipped in a rich dark chocolate coating so decadent we can't reveal the source! Now available for delivery. Orders can be picked up at our kitchen located at 3623 East Independence Blvd. in Charlotte, North Carolina. Please allow 24 hours notice for all orders. All FedEx orders are two day delivery and will ship Monday, Tuesday or Wednesday.

“While I wouldn’t ask him to divulge any trade secrets, I do know that fresh lime zest in Smart’s Key lime custard packs a full punch of flavor. The custard is delicious – not too sweet, not too tart. The chocolate coating and the crunchy crust surrounding the custard inside make the perfect foil to match the creamy confection. Certainly Charlotte’s own Key lime pie on a stick is one of the best frozen treats I’ve had in years.”

Read the full article

Heidi Edidin
Food Critic
Charlotte Weekly Magazine

Local Pickup

Key Lime Pie on a Stick..............................................................$3.50 each

Whole Key Lime Pie...................................................................$16.95 each

Overnight Shipping

(Includes the cost of Styrofoam Cooler, Dry Ice and FedEx 2 day shipping charges)

12 each Key Lime Pie on a Stick........................................................$89.95

24 each Key Lime Pie on a Stick........................................................$149.95

Whole Key Lime Pie..............................................................................$59.95

Prices listed are for the Continental U.S. Only- Call us for rates to Alaska and Hawaii

Key Lime Pie on a Stick

12 each Key Lime Pie on a Stick $89.95 24 each Key Lime Pie on a Stick $149.95

Whole Key Lime Pie

1-Whole Key Lime Pie - 59.95